The new movie Star Wars The Last Jedi is thoughtful and inventive, presenting a new vision of familiar elements such as Luke Skywalker and the Force. Fantasy author Erin Lindsey says those changes have proved too much for some fans of Star Wars
"When people really stick to a property, they acquire a certain sense of entitlement about how history needs develop, "says Lindsey in episode 287 of the podcast of Geek's Guide to the Galaxy . "And when expectations fade, even in a way that should be nice, because having frustrated expectations is sometimes very funny, it's a good thing, it can be disappointing."
But Geek's Guide to the Galaxy Host David Barr Kirtley fully agrees with the vision of director Rian Johnson of the universe Star Wars .
"You could say that this is my favorite Star Wars movie," says Kirtley. "It has the greatest moral complexity of any movie, it has the most surprises of any of the movies, and it's the most intellectual and self-conscious, and it gives you more to think about later."
Science fiction writer Seth Dickinson agrees that The Last Jedi is doing fascinating things with the universe Star Wars particularly when it comes to the surrealistic presentation of the Force in the movie .
"There was a kind of David Lynchian scene in which Rey descends to this 'dark side hole' and encounters a mirror that makes it a causal chain of itself in the past and in the future, "he says. "I thought that scene was fantastic, it was not a pastiche of any other mystical vision, I wanted Rey to have three more of those scenes."
Author Rajan Khanna feels that a certain amount of disorientation and alienation is inevitable, as we begin to lose some of the most familiar actors and characters Star Wars . "They are shaping a world further away from the touchstones we know from Star Wars ," he says, "which I think is why some people start to feel a little weird" [1
David Barr Kirtley in J.J. Abrams:
"My impression of JJ Abrams at this point, and this could be completely unfair, I do not know him or anything, but my impression is that he loves movies, and he knows everything there is to know about movies, and it does not have much to say, while I feel that Rian Johnson has things to say, and I'm afraid this trilogy could easily reflect the first trilogy, where you have the first nice movie for the audience, and then you have the second movie dark and strange that people only in hindsight recognize was the most interesting, and then you have a third person without a mind willing the crowd again and I'm hoping that JJ Abrams will go into the next movie and it will be fun and the good ones will win, and there will be nothing more than that. "
Seth Dickinson in the Force:
"I think Luke realized that there are many, many bad ways to use the Force, one of which is that you become a dark side that You want to take over the galaxy, but it's another thing that you have enough knowledge of the Force to move your sword and kill people who do not have the Force, and you configure yourself like this monastic order of space police, that instead of trying to understand the Universe or enlightenment has just become a tool of the state. "Luke realized that the Jedi order was basically these foolish bureaucrats who were self-deceived and refused to take the next necessary step to study the Force, which is to abandon the and go on their own without doing anything, and I think that's why Luke is not willing to act. "
David Barr Kirtley on Supreme Leader Snoke:
"I do not know if they have to say where Snoke-I came from. They never say where the Emperor came from in the other films, before they came to the prequels and everything, but apparently there are all sorts of things in the books and comics that will explain all of that … Apparently there is material in Chuck Wendig's books, which I have not read, which is a kind of indication that the Emperor had a plan of contingency where all the Imperial forces were going to leave the galaxy and then come back, and they connected with Snoke out there, and he's some kind of alien beyond the edge of the galaxy. I'm sure there's going to be 10 years of books and cartoons that are going to end all at once, and I'm really not too excited about that, I wish there were two lines in the movie that said where it came from, and I would have been happy with that. "
Erin Lindsey in Luke Skywalker:  "It would have made more sense for Luke to become a moody hermit if he was not only indirectly responsible for the fall of Ben Solo, but somehow that part of the reinstatement of the Jedi order was somehow connected to tipping the scales , and tilting the balance is what creates that imbalance that leads the dark side to the ascension again. And it somehow implies that the Jedi have done it in the past, without implying that the Jedi did it this time, so you really do not have an idea of how we got there from here to here. For all these callbacks to the previous series, there is this missing space, both for the dark side and for the light side: how do we get to this point? "
Back to the top Skip to: start of the article.